Skip to content

Cargo liability vs cargo insurance: why carrier liability is not enough

Costs & risks11 min read
Cargo liability vs cargo insurance: why carrier liability is not enough

Many shippers believe that if goods are lost or damaged in transport, the carrier will pay. Sometimes it does. But the amount is often far less than the value of the goods, and in many situations the carrier does not have to pay at all. Cargo insurance closes that gap.

How carrier liability works

The liability of carriers is set by international conventions and by the terms of the transport contract. The main ones are:

  • Sea freight: the Hague Rules and the Hague-Visby Rules (and, in a smaller number of countries, the Hamburg Rules).
  • Road freight: the CMR Convention for international road transport.
  • Air freight: the Montreal Convention, or the older Warsaw system on some routes.

These rules have three things in common:

  1. Liability is limited. Compensation is capped, usually by weight (per kilogram) and, at sea, also per package or unit. The limits are expressed in Special Drawing Rights (SDR), an international unit of account. For light but valuable goods, such as electronics, clothing or medicines, the cap can be a small fraction of the real value.
  2. The carrier has defences. At sea in particular, carriers are not liable for some causes of loss, such as certain navigation errors, fire in some circumstances, perils of the sea or insufficient packing by the shipper.
  3. The process takes time. You must give notice within strict time limits, prove the loss and prove the carrier was responsible. A claim can take months.

The exact limits and conditions depend on the convention, the route and the contract. Ask us if you need the figures for a specific shipment.

Carrier liability limits by mode of transport

The table shows the most a carrier usually pays for lost or damaged goods under each convention. The limits are in SDR (Special Drawing Rights of the International Monetary Fund); one SDR is worth roughly 1.3 to 1.4 US dollars, and the rate changes every day.

Cargo liability limits
Mode Convention Limit Notice of hidden damage Time to go to court
Sea Hague-Visby Rules 2 SDR per kg or 666.67 SDR per package, whichever is higher 3 days 1 year
Sea Hamburg Rules 2.5 SDR per kg or 835 SDR per package 15 days 2 years
Road CMR Convention 8.33 SDR per kg 7 days (Sundays and public holidays excluded) 1 year
Air Montreal Convention (since 28 December 2024) 26 SDR per kg 14 days (21 days for delay) 2 years

Visible damage must be noted on the delivery receipt under every convention. The limits can fall away in a few cases, for example when a higher value was declared on the transport document and an extra charge paid, or, at sea and on the road, when the carrier caused the loss on purpose or recklessly. Under the Montreal Convention the air cargo limit holds even then: only a declared value raises it.

Example: 1,000 kg of electronics worth 50,000 US dollars on 10 pallets

If the whole consignment is lost, the carrier pays at most: by sea under Hague-Visby, 6,667 SDR (10 pallets listed on the bill of lading × 666.67 SDR, more than 1,000 kg × 2 SDR), about 9,000 US dollars; by road under CMR, 8,330 SDR, about 11,200 US dollars; by air, 26,000 SDR, about 35,000 US dollars. The rest of the value is your loss, and all of it if the carrier has a defence, unless the goods are insured.

Carrier liability vs cargo insurance

Carrier liability or cargo insurance
Carrier liability Cargo insurance
Who pays The carrier, only if it is legally responsible Your insurer, whoever caused the loss
How much Capped per kg or per package The insured value, usually invoice plus freight plus 10%
Exceptions Many legal defences: navigation errors, fire, perils of the sea, poor packing Only the exclusions written in the policy
General average Not covered: you pay your share Covered: the insurer gives the guarantee
Getting paid Often months, sometimes after a dispute Usually faster: the insurer pays you, then claims from the carrier

What cargo insurance covers

Cargo insurance protects the value of your goods, regardless of whether the carrier is liable. Most international policies are based on the Institute Cargo Clauses (ICC), which come in three main levels:

  • ICC (A): the widest cover. It covers all risks of loss or damage, except those that are specifically excluded. This is the standard choice for most manufactured goods.
  • ICC (B): covers a list of named events, such as fire, explosion, the sinking or stranding of the vessel, collision, overturning of the truck, earthquake, washing overboard and water entering the vessel or container.
  • ICC (C): the most limited cover. It covers a shorter list of major events, such as fire, explosion, sinking, stranding, collision and general average.

All levels have exclusions, for example loss caused by insufficient packing, ordinary leakage or wear, delay, inherent vice of the goods, or the insured’s wilful misconduct. War and strikes are usually covered only by separate clauses. Read the policy, or ask your insurer to explain what is excluded.

Under the Incoterms 2020 rules, a seller who sells CIP must insure at the ICC (A) level, while a seller who sells CIF only has to provide ICC (C) cover, unless the contract says otherwise. A buyer under CIF may want to buy extra cover.

General average: a risk many shippers do not know

General average is an old principle of maritime law. When a ship and its cargo are in danger, the master may make a deliberate sacrifice or spend money to save the voyage: for example, jettisoning some cargo, fighting a fire or paying for salvage and towing. The cost is then shared by everyone with an interest in the voyage, including the owners of all the cargo on board, in proportion to the value of their goods.

This means you can be asked to pay, even if your own goods arrived undamaged. Before your goods are released, the general average adjuster will require security, usually a guarantee from your insurer or a cash deposit. With insurance, the insurer normally provides the guarantee. Without insurance, you may have to pay a cash deposit, which can be a significant share of the cargo value, before you can collect your goods.

How to insure well

  • Insure the full value. A common basis is the invoice value plus freight and insurance, plus a margin, often 10%, to cover extra costs.
  • Cover the whole journey, from the shipper’s warehouse to the receiver’s, including storage and handling in between.
  • Choose the right clause. ICC (A) for most goods; check special conditions for fragile, perishable or high-value cargo.
  • Pack well. Insurers do not pay for damage caused by poor packing. Our guide to packing and palletising for export explains the basics.
  • Act quickly after a loss. Note any damage on the delivery receipt, take photos, keep the packaging and notify the carrier and the insurer within the time limits.

Cargo legal liability: who has to prove what

A cargo claim follows the same logic under every convention. You show that the carrier received the goods in good condition and that they were lost, damaged or late when it delivered them. A clean bill of lading, a CMR consignment note or an air waybill without reservations is the usual proof of the first part; the delivery receipt and a survey report prove the second. The carrier is then presumed liable, unless it proves one of the defences its convention allows.

  • Sea, Hague-Visby Rules: a long list of exceptions, including errors in navigating or managing the ship, fire not caused by the carrier’s own fault, perils of the sea, insufficient packing and inherent vice of the goods.
  • Road, CMR Convention: the claimant’s own fault or instructions, inherent vice, circumstances the carrier could not avoid, and special risks such as goods carried in an open vehicle by agreement, poor packing, or loading and unloading done by the sender or the consignee.
  • Air, Montreal Convention: only a few: inherent defect of the cargo, defective packing by someone other than the carrier, an act of war, or an act of a public authority.

Which rules apply depends on the contract and the route; the bill of lading or the carrier’s terms usually say so.

Cargo liability insurance: the carrier’s cover, not yours

Carriers and forwarders buy liability insurance: CMR liability cover for road hauliers, freight forwarder’s liability insurance, P&I cover for shipowners. It pays what the carrier legally owes, up to the convention limits, and it protects the carrier, not your goods. So “is the truck insured?” does not tell you whether your cargo is covered. If the carrier has a defence, or the loss is above the limit, its liability insurance pays you nothing. Only cargo insurance, bought for the goods, covers their value.

Liability for delay

  • Road (CMR): the carrier is liable when the goods are not delivered within the agreed time, or a reasonable time, and the claimant proves a loss; compensation is limited to the carriage charges.
  • Air (Montreal): the carrier is liable for delay unless it took all reasonable measures to avoid it, within the same 26 SDR per kg limit.
  • Sea: the Hague-Visby Rules do not set a delay limit; under the Hamburg Rules it is two and a half times the freight of the delayed goods, at most the total freight.

Cargo insurance usually excludes loss caused by delay. For time-critical shipments, plan buffers and agree delivery dates in writing.

Making a cargo claim, step by step

  1. At delivery, write any visible damage precisely on the delivery receipt or the CMR before you sign: “3 cartons crushed, pallet 4 wet”, not just “damaged”.
  2. For hidden damage, send written notice to the carrier in time: 3 days at sea under Hague-Visby, 15 days under the Hamburg Rules, 7 days by road (Sundays and public holidays excluded), 14 days by air.
  3. Keep the goods and the packaging, take photos, and ask the carrier and your insurer to send a surveyor.
  4. Send the claim in writing with the commercial invoice, packing list, transport document, survey report and your calculation.
  5. Tell your insurer at once. It pays you under the policy and then claims from the carrier in your place.
  6. Watch the time limit for going to court: one year at sea under Hague-Visby and by road, two years by air and under the Hamburg Rules.

What is cargo legal liability?

It is the carrier’s responsibility, under a transport convention or the contract, for goods lost, damaged or delayed while in its care. It is presumed once you prove the loss, it can be avoided by the defences the convention allows, and it is limited per kilogram or per package.

Who pays if the carrier is not liable?

You do, unless the goods are insured. Cargo insurance pays for the insured risks whoever caused the loss, including cases where the carrier has a defence.

Does cargo liability cover delay?

Partly. Road and air carriers answer for delay within limits, and the Hamburg Rules set a limit at sea; the Hague-Visby Rules do not. Cargo insurance usually excludes delay.

Do you need it?

If losing the goods would hurt your business, the answer is almost always yes. The premium is usually a small percentage of the cargo value. When you ask Kyranis Logistics for a quote for air, ocean, road or express freight, ask us about cargo insurance too. We can talk through the level of cover that suits your goods and your route.

Questions about cargo liability

What is cargo liability?

Cargo liability is the carrier's legal responsibility for the goods from the moment it takes them over until it delivers them. It is set by the transport conventions and the contract, and it is limited.

Is the carrier's liability the same as insurance?

No. Liability only pays when the carrier is at fault and has no defence, and only up to the limit. Insurance pays for the insured risks, up to the insured value, whoever is at fault.

Can I raise the carrier's limit?

Sometimes. You can declare a higher value on the bill of lading or air waybill and pay an extra charge. Many carriers do not offer it, and it usually costs more than cargo insurance.

Does my freight forwarder's liability cover the goods?

A forwarder's liability is also limited, by its trading conditions or by the convention when it acts as the carrier. It does not replace cargo insurance.

How much does cargo insurance cost?

Usually a small percentage of the insured value, depending on the goods, the packing, the route and the cover. Ask for it together with your freight quote.

Planning a shipment? Request a quote with every fee included upfront, or talk to our team in Tunisia: +216 70 295 255, info@kyranislogistics.com.

Share it

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments appear once we have read them.